Methodology
Evidence & sources
Every claim on this site is labelled by how well-supported it is, and every source is named rather than vaguely gestured at ("studies show…"). This page explains what those labels mean, where the body-map data comes from, and the honest limits of an educational website.
Every practice on this site carries one of three tags. They're our reading of the evidence base for that specific claim, not a guarantee about your personal results.
Well-supported
Backed by replicated randomized controlled trials, or a large, consistent body of research, cited by name (e.g. Balban et al., 2023 for the physiological sigh; Jacobson et al., 1996 for behavioral activation). This is the strongest tier we use — it does not mean "guaranteed to work for you," only that controlled research consistently finds an effect.
Promising
Smaller studies, mechanistic evidence, a single well-designed trial not yet replicated, or research from an adjacent but related question. Worth trying, held a little more loosely than the well-supported tier — we say so explicitly wherever a claim rests on one surprising trial (the SMILES dietary trial for depression is a good example).
Anecdotal
Clinical or traditional report only, with no controlled studies behind it. We still include a small number of anecdotal practices where they're widely used and low-risk (nasal breathing as a stress habit; certain spiritual or contemplative framings), but we say plainly that the evidence isn't there yet, rather than dressing up a report as a finding.
The colored body-activation maps on each emotion page aren't illustrations — most are directly measured data.
The primary dataset
- Source: Nummenmaa, L., Glerean, E., Hari, R., & Hietanen, J. K. (2014). Bodily maps of emotions. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(2), 646–651.
- Method: over 700 participants across five experiments were shown emotion-inducing words, stories, films, and facial expressions, then asked to color in a body silhouette showing where they felt increased or decreased activation. The resulting maps were statistically consistent across cultures and experiment types.
- What's labelled “measured” on this site: the core emotions this study covered directly — anger, fear, disgust, happiness, sadness, surprise, and several secondary and positive states it extended to in follow-up work.
- What's labelled “approximated”: states this specific study didn't measure directly (compassion is the clearest example) — for these, the map is our informed approximation from adjacent research (compassion-focused therapy neuroimaging, self-compassion studies), and we say so on the page.
One optional, clearly-marked exception to the evidence-first approach.
A heuristic, not a measurement
Several pages offer an optional toggle showing where a feeling calibrates on David Hawkins' Map of Consciousness. We're explicit every time it appears: this is a spiritual/philosophical ordering, not empirical science, it never orders anything by default, and it's included because some readers find it a useful map to think with — not because it's been validated the way the body-map data has.
What an educational website can and can't do, stated plainly.
What this is
- Psychoeducation — explaining mechanisms, offering evidence-tagged practices, and pointing toward when professional care is the right next step.
- A companion to the book Lemonade by Irynka Kis, and to a growing set of interactive self-reflection tools.
What this isn't
- Diagnosis, treatment, or therapy. No page on this site forms a therapist-client or doctor-patient relationship.
- A substitute for a professional when you need one — every guide on this site says so, and our when-not-to-use-this page says it in full.
- Personalized medical advice. Quiz and tool results are, in the quiz's own words, “a gentle mirror, not a diagnosis or therapy.”
If you need support right now
This page is about methodology, not crisis support. If you're in distress, please see our support & crisis lines page instead.
Curious about a specific claim on a specific page? Every guide and emotion page lists its sources at the bottom, by name. For the book this site accompanies, see About the book.